The volcanoes are the first thing we saw at dawn and the last thing we saw at dusk. From 30 miles offshore on Guatemala’s Pacific coast, the cones of Agua, Fuego and Pacaya stand above the haze on the horizon like a painted backdrop, and on the mornings when Fuego was venting, a thin plume of ash bent east in the trade wind. Between those mountains and the boat lay the most reliable sailfish water we have ever fished. We spent five days out of Iztapa in late January, and we came home with a new understanding of what the words “numbers fishery” actually mean.
Getting there
Iztapa is a small town on the coast of Escuintla department, about 70 miles by road south of Guatemala City. The drive down from the highlands takes two hours, dropping from 5,000 feet through coffee and sugarcane country to the flat, hot coastal plain. The sportfishing boats keep to the estuary behind the beach, on the Rio Maria Linda where it joins the long canal that runs parallel to the coast, a few miles east of the commercial port at Puerto Quetzal. Every morning the fleet idles down the river in the dark and crosses the bar at the river mouth, which on a big Pacific swell is the most exciting 200 yards of the day.
The season runs from November through May. December to April is the peak, when the water offshore settles into the low 80s Fahrenheit and the sailfish concentrate along the current edges. The fishing grounds lie 20 to 45 miles out, over deep water where converging currents build the temperature breaks and color changes that hold bait.
The ride offshore
The Pacific here is not the Gulf of Mexico. The swell rolls in from storms thousands of miles away, long and heavy, six to ten feet from trough to crest on our first morning but with a period of 14 seconds or more, so the boat rose and fell over it without a slam. The wind was light, under 10 knots, which is typical in the dry season. Our boat, a 35 foot open sportfisher, ran at 22 knots for an hour and a half to reach the area the captain had marked the day before, with the volcanoes shrinking astern and nothing else in sight but a few pangas and the occasional sea turtle.
Along the way we passed through the debris lines the Guatemalan coast is known for: logs, branches and mats of vegetation carried out by the rivers, each one a small ecosystem of dorado and triggerfish. We stopped at one long enough to pull three dorado, then left them for the sailfish.
How the fishing works
Guatemala’s fleet fishes sailfish almost exclusively with the bait-and-switch. Hookless teasers, usually a pair of dredges below the surface and two or three squid chains or daisy chains behind the boat, are trolled at 7 or 8 knots. A sailfish comes up on a teaser, lit up in electric blue and purple with its sail raised, and slashes at it. The mate pulls the teaser away, the angler drops back a rigged ballyhoo on a 7/0 non-offset circle hook, and the fish, if all goes well, eats the bait instead. The angler counts to three, lets the line come tight, and winds.
Circle hooks are the rule here, not a preference. Guatemala made the release of all billfish law more than two decades ago, and the local fleet adopted circle hooks on its own well before that requirement was widely accepted elsewhere. In five days we did not see a J hook on the boat, and we did not see a single sailfish hooked anywhere but the corner of the jaw.
The tackle is light for the size of the fish: 20 pound conventional outfits with 60 to 80 pound fluorocarbon leaders. A Pacific sailfish of 80 to 110 pounds on that gear is a fair fight, over in 10 to 20 minutes, and the fish arrives at the boat still strong enough to be revived and released in a couple of minutes.
What a 20 fish day feels like
On our first day we raised 22 sailfish, had 17 bites and released 12. That, the mate told us without irony, was a slow day. On our third day the count was 38 raised, 29 bites, 21 released, and by early afternoon we had stopped counting the ones that came up and did not eat. Two anglers taking turns, two mates working the teasers and the baits, and a captain on the bridge calling fish before any of us saw them: the rhythm of it becomes almost mechanical after the tenth release.
What it feels like is hard to convey. The first sailfish of a life is an event; the twentieth in a single day is still an event, but a different kind. By the afternoon the pleasure had shifted from the fish themselves to the craft: the drop-back, the count, the moment the line came tight and the fish went airborne 50 yards off the transom, tail-walking and greyhounding in the long swell with the sun on its sail. We stopped keeping score somewhere in the middle of the fourth day and simply fished.
Release ethics in a numbers fishery
A fishery that produces 20 sailfish a day per boat puts a question to every angler who fishes it: what does all that catching do to the fish? The Guatemalan answer is a set of practices that we thought were the best we had seen anywhere. Fish are never lifted from the water. The mate takes the leader, removes the hook with a dehooker or cuts the leader an inch from the hook, and holds the fish by the bill while the captain idles forward until it kicks free. Photographs are taken over the side in the time it takes the fish to recover. The boat carries no gaff on the sailfish spread.
Tagging programmes have run out of this coast for years, and satellite tag studies of Pacific sailfish released on circle hooks have shown survival rates that make the fishery defensible. It is still a fishery that depends on anglers behaving well, and in a week of watching a dozen boats work the same water, we did not see one that did not.
The tally
Five days: 141 sailfish raised, 93 bites, 71 releases, plus one blue marlin of perhaps 300 pounds that ate a ballyhoo meant for a sailfish and was released after 40 minutes. We paid for the boat, the fuel and the crew at the rates the fleet charges, which for a full day on a boat of that size run between 900 and 1,500 dollars depending on the season and the boat. We would go back tomorrow, and the volcanoes would still be there.